See Why
Customer Reviews
"We were passing through town and were looking for at local breakfast place. This hit the spot. We received a friendly greeting as we entered the restaurant. We chose a cozy booth in the original part of this 1950's diner. There have been obvious updates, but the telltale diner ceiling was clearly evident.
We came for the food and were totally satisfied with our meals. My husband had the deadly good breakfast burrito with bacon and a side of home fries. I chose pancakes and a side of bacon. The three huge pancakes were excellent as was the bacon. We had a very nice waitress who took our order and promptly brought our breakfast. Skip the chains, come to Muller's for personal service and delicious, fresh food.."
​
- Anne P.
"This place was cute. Good service and nice people. Food is standard American but they took the time to make my 4 year old's pancake in the shape of Mickey Mouse. Lots of local color and a great way to see small town American life.."
​
- Sarah B.
" I visit the Muller's Port Jervis Diner quite frequently. I love their Manhattan Clam Chowder. Mostly typical diner food serving breakfast all day as well. Food has always been good and fresh. Service no matter who is serving is always excellent, friendly in a small town way. Excellent stop for both local folk and those passing through town."
"We like to hit Port Jervis area to buy antiques and vintage items. This time I brought a crew of seven with me. The staff greeted us and put us together for a nice lunch. I ordered breakfast. My order was standard and it was good diner food and lot's of it. It is located on a corner in the middle of town. I recommend breakfast if you go."
​
- Chuck Bennette
"After reading some of the reviews for this diner we decided to give it a try as we drove through that area. It is located at a busy cross roads in the downtown area of Port Jervis. The old sign outside the diner just says Port Jervis Diner. No mention of Mullers. It's the type of place that I would not have considered going in to if I hadn't read the reviews. The place is old but clean and the staff are pleasant and attentive. I ordered the "Little Lady" breakfast. If this was little I don't know what large would look like. My husband ordered the hamburger. Both of our dishes were obviously cooked for us. They were fresh and hot and we both enjoyed them."
​
- Jean W.
"Found this diner by accident off I-84. Great food. Good friendy service and Mac & Cheese to die for. Hand cut burgers. Everyone there looked like locals. Would go back."
​
- Ron T.